The Banach–Tarski Paradox in Isabelle/HOL

Arthur Freitas Ramos 📧, David Barros Hulak 📧 and Ruy Jose Guerra Barretto de Queiroz 📧

May 7, 2026

Abstract

We formalise in Isabelle/HOL the classical Banach–Tarski paradox for the closed unit ball in three-dimensional Euclidean space. The development proves the free-group paradox, the free subgroup of SO(3), the Hausdorff paradox away from a countable bad set, the absorption arguments for the sphere and the origin, and the final finite-partition theorem for the ball. The proof follows the standard route: the paradoxical decompo sition of the free group on two generators F2, the existence of a free subgroup F2 ≤ SO(3) via the AFP Free-Groups entry, the Hausdorff paradox for S2 \ D where D is a countable set of fixed points, and absorption arguments extending the partition to S2, then radially to B3\{0}, and finally to B3 itself. The argument crucially relies on the axiom of choice.

License

BSD License

Note

Codex with gpt 5.5 on xhigh was used to help with the proof engineering.

Topics

Session Banach_Tarski

Depends on